My Response to the post of Cenon Bibe dated December 6, 2012 and is located in his Facebook group — Answering Muslims.
NO PROOF THAT GABRIEL REVEALED THE QURAN
BEN LANGCUYAN, a MUSLIM, CLAIMS that the ANGEL GABRIEL REVEALED the QURAN to the PROPHET of ISLAM.
LANGCUYAN said, Qur’an being stage by stage taught by Angel Gabriel to Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him is in PRIVATE.
To Ben Langcuyan, WHO SAW or HEARD ANGEL GABRIEL REVEAL the QURAN to YOUR PROPHET?
The STORY of GABRIEL REVEALING THE QURAN to YOUR PROPHET is ONLY A CLAIM of YOUR PROPHET. IT CAN NEVER BE SUPPORTED by ANY WITNESS or BY ANY EVIDENCE.
Cenon Bibe is clearly WRONG here. I already said that the revelations is IN PRIVATE. So, there is NO NEED that Gabriel should display his self physically and/or make his voice be heard during revelations. That is why there no such thing as EYE WITNESSES seeing Gabriel in physical form nor heard him.
But there is an evidence — the Qur’an:
“Your companion (Muhammad SAW) has neither gone astray nor erred. Nor does he speak of (his own) desire. It is only an Inspiration that is inspired. He has been taught (this Quran) by one mighty in power [Jibrael (Gabriel)].”
We Muslims believe firmly in the Qur’an. It is nothing to us and certainly not our problem if non-Muslims do not (or will not) believe in the Qur-an.
Two examples of clear Prophecies that proved the truthfulness of the Quran are:
1. Quran 111 prophecied that Abu Lahab will never embrace Islam. The prophecy is revealed 10 years before his death. And he died as a non-Muslim. The Prophecy did happened.
2. Quran 30:1-6 prophesied the victory Romans over the Persians. The prophecy is revealed about 2 years before the victory. The Prophecy did happened.
In fact in a SUPPOSED “REVELATION” made by this “ANGEL,” the SAHABA (companions of YOUR PROPHET) NEVER SAW or HEARD ANYONE SPEAK ASIDE FROM YOUR PROPHET.
See my response above AGAIN. I already said that the revelations is IN PRIVATE. So, there is NO NEED that Gabriel should display his self physically and/or make his voice be heard during revelations. That is why there no such thing as EYE WITNESSES seeing Gabriel in physical form nor heard him.
SAHIH HADITH BUKHARI 29:56
Narrated ‘Abdullah: While we were in the company of the Prophet in a cave at Mina, when Surat-wal-Mursalat were revealed and he recited it and I heard it (directly) from his mouth as soon as he recited its revelation. Suddenly a snake sprang at us and the Prophet said (ordered us): “Kill it.” We ran to kill it but it escaped quickly. The Prophet said, “It has escaped your evil and you too have escaped its evil.”
FROM WHOSE MOUTH did the SAHABA HEAR the SUPPOSED REVELATION? Was it from this “ANGEL”?
The “supposed” “Sahih” Hadith is presented here “by Cenon Bibe.” Non-Christians around the world experienced so much deceptions techniques and falsehoods from Christian missionaries and apologists. With their notorious preaching signature, WE DO NOT KNOW if the “Hadith presented by Cenon Bibe” is “true and without EDITIONS by him or by anyone,” or not.
So far, I have not yet checked the “status” of “Hadith he presented.”
Again, see my response above.
So, WHERE WAS the “ANGEL”?
THERE WAS NO ANGEL.
Again, see my response above. 😀